Archive for the ‘Parent Alienation’ Category

Parent Alienation Comment/question

Larry writes:

You often site examples of Jon’s children. Who is Jon?, your husbamd or the guy you’re shacked up with? Is shacking up the reason that his ex is so difficult to get along with. Is it the reason that she trys to limit his activities with the children? Maybe if you all were legally married things would change. What is your relationship like with your children. Assuming you have children because of all the advice you offer about parenting.

Sonia says:  Larry….Jon is in fact my significant other.  In my opinion, and you are entitled to yours, whether Jon and I are married or not is of no consequence at this time.  Jon’s ex wife had made it her mission to alienate him from his kids long before I entered the picture.  I just happened to be the person who exposed it….and since then, my stepson has chosen to come to live with us.
I think that the point here that I would like to make is that it is important in these cases to look very hard at both sides unconditionally.  One parent should not be allowed to hammer the other.  Ever.  The issues between the biological parents should be kept seperate at all times. There should always be a priority system in place where the custodial parent initiates contact with the other parent, especially if distance is involved. 
 When I asked my stepson why he didn’t call his dad when he missed him, his response was that his dad was out of site, so he tried to put him out of mind.  He was just being a kid and going on with things.  It bothered him, but his mom told him that if his dad wanted to talk to him he would call or come there.  So that’s the way he looked at it.  It didn’t ever occur to him, as a child, that his dad was calling and trying to see him or that his mom was discouraging that communication.  And….not encouraging IS discouraging.
As far as whether I have kids or not…since I give my therapeutic opinions on parenting:  Knowledge does not have to be experienced to be understood.  I have never been sexually abused and I work with abuse victims.  I have never been a drug addict, but I am an addictive disorder specialist.  I am an adolescent specialist as well…..but I have been an adolescent, so I guess I am safe there.  And…I have experienced parent alienation….so seems I am safe there too.  I tend to write the most about things that I have experienced.  So I guess we are both right, huh?
Thank you for your comment…

Insight vs. Instinct….

Insight is knowing why you know something…..instinct requires no voluntary action

Results of parent alienation

When a parent alienates their child from the other rightful parent, it disrupts their moral content.  It disrupts their ability to develop their value system properly.  It disrupts their ability to come to conclusions or decisions rationally.  They are forced,.sometimes abruptly ,to choose who to go “against”. They learn that choices or decisions don’t necessarily require negotiation, or gathering of information.  The most important thing becomes not upsetting the alienating parent….because they are usually the ones who have primary custody and essentially make most of their “choices” anyway.  Keep peace…..keep it quiet.

Maybe this is what is wrong with our country….bad parenting. 

Of course, you know I have to give an example:  Jon’s kids are so brainwashed that they sincerely believe that he is useless, irresponsible, broke, and not interested in them.  Why?  Well, that is what they have been told for 20 years.  Why didn’t he fight it?  He did….but he ran out of money.  Then what?  The kids lived hundreds of miles away….and still do.  How far do you go when your kids don’t want to see you anyway?  When they have been completely cut off from his side of the family like they never existed?  He tries to keep up with his 17 year old son.  We made several attempts to see him in the past year.  The visits usually lasted about 15 minutes to and hour and a half.  He won’t come to see us….it would upset his mom too much.  He now lives with his uncle because his mom threatened to die before she allowed her son to live with his father.  That’s pretty sick.  Recently  the child put up a picture of himself (at like 3 years old) with his step dad.  His step dad is listed as his dad….because he has been told that his real dad has never been there…and so that is what they believe.  They were pretty young when the divorce happened, so it’s not exactly hard to change or influence the memories that kids have in their little heads.   So it didn’t matter that he showed up at their doorstep  for visitation to have the door slammed in his face….or that his ex wife declared his company in bankruptcy after they were divorced, forcing him into financial duress.  It didn’t matter  how many cards, or phone calls, or attempts that he made….they were still being told on a regular basis that their dad was not there, didn’t care , that he never fought for them and that he just sucked as a human…. 

And so he does….in their eyes.  And so they move into their adulthood with half the truth.  Are they going to have healthy relationships? Or are they going to repeat cycles.  Their mother was abandoned by her father… she repeated the cycle and recreated that with her own kids.  She has single handedly created a situation that looks just like hers.  It looks like Jon abandoned his kids like her father abandoned her.  It’s just so tragic….and abusive.  Therapy would have been a much better option.  What a horrible thing to do to your own children.

We are at the mercy of our unwillingness to create a new thought…


Luck is where opportunity meets preparedness……(said by one of my clients)

Unconditional love and acceptance

It’s hard to walk away from unconditional love and acceptance….so offer it up, even when you don’t want to….the results will astound you, I promise.  When you get really good at it, your mind finds a sense of peace…lower stress and accountability with yourself.


Integrity is more than just honoring your word….it is completing the task as it is meant to be done.

Parent Alienation: more signs and symptoms…..

We left off at #10 last time….so to continue with #11.

11. The child is owned, controlled, and indoctrinated by the alienating parent.  That parent is viewed as all good, all wise, and all poerful by the child who becomes dependent, manipulated by them.  There is never questioning that what the parent says or does is always right.

(just recently, Jon’s son called and wanted to come and live with us.  He has just been thru a residential treatment facility.  Interestingly enough, when his mother got wind of it….she threw an absolute fit.  Now he lives with his uncle, or her brother.  She told him that she would rather die than have him live with his father.  Then she threatened to take Jon to court even though she is the one in contempt.  She simply makes it so difficult for her son to have a relationship with his dad that he just succumbs to it.  He can’t take the pressure or the fear that she will abandon him.

12. The child tends to paraphrase statements used by the alienating parent.  The words used are often untypical of words likely to be used by a child.  It is very similar to a cult type of indoctrination.

(Jon called his 7 year old son on Thanksgiving morning to say happy turkey day and his son said….”dad, stop calling here and harassing my family”.  We could not believe it.  Harass?  He didn’t even know what that meant!  His mother grabbed the phone and said, “stop calling here you weirdo”.  This is a true story.  A grown woman who is a parent, said that.)

13. The child suffers from paranoia (hatred) inculcated by the alienating parent who promotes attitudes, intentions, and behaviors of a negative nature to the alienated parent.

(Again, Jon’s ex would tell his son not to take any medicines and to be careful what he ate.  He was told that he had to call her before he went  to bed so she could make sure he was ok.  So his son was afraid that his father was going to give him “drugs”.  He locked himself in the bathroom and would only talk to me.  Thank goodness I was able to explain that this simply was not true.  But….then he went home and got indoctrinated again.

14. The child will speak about exaggerated or contrived abuse that has been experienced from the alienated parent.

(Jon’s daughter wrote a letter to him saying that her mother had to call DFACS on him because he was drunk while they were with him…and that she had to come all the way up from Florida to get them.  Never happened, but the memory was put in her head when she was a kid and she believes her mom.)

(Another good one was from his son….”dad isn’t that the big white house you kicked me and mom out of?”.   Again, never happened.  There was moving, but no “kicking out”.)

15. The child or alienating parent makes statements insinuating quasi or actual sexual, emotional, or physical abuse suffered by the child.

(This is very common.  Jon was not allowed to see his son for months when his ex accused him of physical abuse.  She even made false 911 calls to have him arrested.  Then he had to go thru supervised visitation which, of course, has a negative affecct on the relationship and makes the implication that he is guilty.  It took over a year to prove her wrong.  That is a year lost with the child)

16. The language comes indirectly from the alienator such as, “he touches me inappropriately” or “he has penetrated me,” These are all borrowed scenarios from the alienating parent.

17. Children who are alienated no longer know what the truth is.

(And so they shut down.  They just try to stay where it is safe and forget the other parent.  It’s easier.  There is not way a child could know how to process information this complicated, so they either compartmenatize it , ignore it, or act out.  If they acto out, it is going to be blamed on the alienated paretnt as abuse or abandonment.  Often, we see stomach problems or sleep problems or eating problems as well.)

18. The child who is alienated against the parent will often be alienated against the parent’s family also.

(Grandparents have rights.  It’s hard to exercise in court, but they have rights.  Jon’s kids have not seen or heard the voice of their grandparents in years.  His parents send cards and gifts with no response.  His ex responded one Christmas and said in a card, “Thanks for thinking of us”.  It is inconcievable to me that a person would keep their kids from their grandparents and their cousins.  )

19. The alienator will also poison the child against the therapist unless the therapist supports the alienator.  Hence the therapist is seen as an enemy in the same light as the alienated parent.

(This is where confidentiality becomes very important.  It is imperative that the therapist not base his or her opinion on one side of the story.  I never, ever make a judgement without consulting both sides several times.  The emotional development of a child could depend on me doing a little extra investigation.

20. It is not what the alienator says, but how it is said.  For expample when telling a child “father would like to take you out”, it can be said with joy and enthusiasm indicating positive expectations or it can be said with venom indicating negative feelings. This is what is predominantly communicated to the child rather than the verbal message.

(I have said a million times.  It  is the responsibility of the primary, custodial parent to encourage and maintain the relationship with the other parent.  Period.  Saying “your relationship with your son is your problem.  I have nothing to do with it”…is simply immature and wrong.  Period.)



You can have anything you want in this lifetime, it’s all in your approach.  So if your approach sucks…so will your results.

Parent Alienation: some signs and symptoms

This is from a publication by Ludwig Lowenstein, Ph.d in 2005.  The stuff in italics is from Sonia.

A number of signs or indicators of alienation can be identified. It should be recognized that not all these signs appear in all cases…This unfortuately tends to be the father (being alienated), but there are cases where the mother is alienated also.  Whomever uses alienation procedures or brainwashing to get the child to hate the other parent is clearly in the wrong and is guilty of causing harm to the child in the present and future.  The is considerable research indicating the harm that is done to children who are alienated against a parent when they are young….

It should also be noted that the alienating parent usually has some individuation issues and a personality disorder….ie. has a hard time seperating themselves as a person from their children and in effect lives thru them very inappropriately.  Hence the alienator gives the appearance of being a wonderful and doting parent when in reality  there is little concern about the welfare of the children….just their own vengeance toward the other parent.  You will see cases where the primary mission of the alienating parent is to destroy the other parent in any and every way possible even at the expense of emotionally disrupting the children or basically brainwashing them.

Here are some signs per Dr. Lowenstein:

1. Lack of independent thinking from the child imitating the alienator’s thoughts and feelings.

2. Destroying mail or even presents from the alienated parent.  Jon’s ex wife never gave any of the cards or packages that he sent to his kids, to his kids.  I even sent them some to see if it was true.  They never got anything.  When he called, she would just hang up the phone and tell the kids he never tried to contact them.  She did this a couple of months ago, even after more than 10 years.

3. the alienating parent tends to seek to curtail all communication between the child and the alienated parent.

4.The alienated parent is seen as the scapegoat. he or she is blamed for everything that has gone wrong with the child.  There is no sense of ambivalence.

5. The child calls the alienated parent a liar and other abusive names similar to the alienating parent. 

6. The child insults, shows disrespect, and humiliates the alienated parent often in front of the alienator.

7. Alienated parents are viewed as being despicable, faulty and deserving of being rejected permanently.

8. Parents who alienate children are seducing the child emotionally and will continue to do this while in control of the child, yet they deny that they are doing anything but encouraging the child to make contact with the alienated parent.  I could write a book on this myself.  This indicator is the key to alienation in my opinion.  Once they seduce the child, there is no turning back.  A child is going to listen to the parent that they feel is most unconditional….so when the alienator puts themselves in that position successfully…..their job is set for the long term.

9. The child is made to feel guilty for any love shown towards the alienated parent.  The child will deny any involvement with the alienated parent, fearful of what the alienator would do to him or her.  The child will tell you this until he or she realizes what is happening.  They know that it’s not safe to talk about their feelings toward the alienated parent…but they will tell the alienated parent what they feel and ask questions until they feel threatened by the alienator.

10. The child fears rejection by the programmer/ brainwasher/alienator so  wishes to say good things about the alienated parent or wishes to be with him or her are kept secret.

This is a start.  There are 28 indicators, so I’ll post some others later.


Sonia Confidential
Want to ask Sonia a question and keep it strictly between the two of you? Then click here to enter Sonia Confidential.
Sessions with Sonia
If you live in Georgia and would like to schedule an in-person appointment with Sonia, please contact her at her practice, The Center for Awareness and Evolvement.
My Zimbio